Back when I was in graduate school studying painting, my studio was in a large open area, so anyone with access to the building could see my work in progress. More often than I care to admit other grad students would tell me how disappointed they were to see that I had destroyed a beautiful work of art. They say they would come in one day and see something they really liked only to come in the next day to see it destroyed. At my insistence they began to leave little notes saying they like a piece or simply to stop because it was done.
When I paint, I am often confronted with that question . . . is it done?
As I have grown older I tend to have a bit more restraint when painting. I am not sure that is necessarily a good thing, but it is what it is. So, the painting I have chosen to share today is a piece that has been hanging on my wall for about a year and a half. When I stopped working on it I couldn’t say for sure if it was done or not, but I didn’t want to destroy it in haste. I think about 6 months ago I decided it needed more work. So today it gets a facelift.
From Art & Fear:
“The development of an imagined piece into an actual piece is a progression of decreasing possibilities, as each step in execution reduces further options by converting one — and only one — possibility into a reality. Finally, at some point or another, the piece could not be other than it is, and it is done.
I wrote that first bit before I began working. When my wife saw me pull the painting off the living room wall, she screamed, “Don’t!! I like that painting and you always go too far!”
I painted anyway. But that being said the changes that I made are very subtle and I am sure I was more careful in an effort to avoid an upset spose. For the most part I only used yellow and white. I now realize the yellow areas in the carp didn’t work because it was mostly made up of a single layer of thin paint, while the other areas of paint had a much richer build up of color. If you look closely you can see the changes but I think they would only be obvious if one were looking at them with the naked eye.
I consider myself lucky today because subtle changes satisfied my eye. Quite often one small change progressively leads way to big changes.

Before and after images of final finishes to the painting.

Detail of changes to carp painting. Before and after.